Understanding Recessions and Their Impact on US Markets
As economic uncertainty looms in 2025, American investors are reevaluating how different asset classes behave when the economy slows. A recession, as defined by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), is a significant decline in economic activity that lasts more than a few months and affects real GDP, employment, industrial output, and retail sales. While no two recessions are identical, their ripple effects on financial markets can be profound-making it essential to understand what drives them and how portfolios can be structured to withstand the downturn.
Historically, US recessions have stemmed from a variety of triggers: aggressive interest rate hikes by the Federal Reserve, global supply shocks like pandemics or energy disruptions, financial system collapses, or a broad pullback in consumer demand. The 2001 dot-com crash led to a mild contraction, while the 2008 financial crisis and 2020 pandemic shock caused deep, widespread disruptions. Each event reshaped investor behavior and exposed vulnerabilities in traditional asset allocations. NBER’s historical business cycle data offers a detailed look at these patterns, helping today’s investors anticipate potential risks.
Equities in a Recession: Risks, Realities, and Resilience
For most US investors, equities-stocks traded on exchanges like the NYSE and NASDAQ-form the backbone of long-term wealth building. But during a recession, stock markets often face steep declines. As economic activity slows, corporate revenues shrink, layoffs rise, and profit margins compress. These fundamentals translate into falling stock prices, especially for companies tied to consumer spending and industrial growth.
Market volatility spikes during downturns, driven by fear, uncertainty, and rapid shifts in investor sentiment. The S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average typically see double-digit drawdowns, sometimes exceeding 30% in severe recessions. However, not all sectors suffer equally. Defensive industries-such as healthcare, utilities, and consumer staples-tend to hold up better because demand for essentials like medicine, electricity, and groceries remains stable even in tough times. In contrast, cyclical sectors like technology, travel, and luxury goods often face steep sell-offs due to their reliance on discretionary spending.
The risks for equity investors during a recession go beyond paper losses. Companies may cut or suspend dividends, and weaker firms could face bankruptcy. The challenge lies in identifying high-quality businesses with strong balance sheets, consistent cash flow, and pricing power-firms that can not only survive but potentially emerge stronger. For long-term investors, downturns can also present buying opportunities, though timing the market remains a high-risk strategy.
Commodities in a Recession: Safe Havens or Volatile Bets?
Commodities-raw materials like crude oil, gold, natural gas, copper, and agricultural products-behave very differently from stocks during economic downturns. Because they’re tied to physical supply and demand rather than corporate earnings, their price movements depend heavily on the nature of the recession itself.
Gold, in particular, has long been viewed as a “safe haven” asset. When stock markets plunge and confidence wavers, investors often flock to gold as a store of value. Its historical negative correlation with equities makes it a powerful diversifier, especially during periods of high inflation or geopolitical tension. Silver and other precious metals can play a similar role, though with greater volatility.
Industrial commodities tell a different story. Copper and crude oil are highly sensitive to global economic activity. In a demand-driven recession-where consumers and businesses pull back-prices for these materials often fall. But if the downturn stems from a supply shock, such as a conflict disrupting oil shipments or a manufacturing bottleneck, energy and metal prices can spike dramatically. This dynamic played out in 2022 and early 2023, when post-pandemic supply chain issues contributed to inflationary pressures despite slowing growth-a phenomenon known as stagflation.
While commodities can serve as an effective inflation hedge, they come with unique risks. Prices are notoriously volatile, influenced by weather, geopolitics, and speculative trading. Physical storage adds cost and complexity, though most investors gain exposure through futures contracts or ETFs, which mitigate these issues. Still, contango (when future prices exceed spot prices) can erode returns in futures-based funds, and tax treatment varies depending on the investment vehicle.
Commodities vs. Equities: A Strategic Comparison for 2025
As the US economy approaches 2025, investors must weigh the contrasting roles of commodities and equities in a recession-resistant portfolio. The outcome hinges not just on whether a recession occurs, but on its underlying cause. A demand-led downturn calls for defensive positioning, while a supply-driven crisis may create opportunities in select commodities.
| Feature | Equities (Stocks) | Commodities (Raw Materials) |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Role | Growth, long-term capital appreciation | Inflation hedge, portfolio diversification, safe haven |
| Recession Impact | Generally negative (earnings compression, volatility) | Mixed (some rise, some fall based on demand/supply) |
| Inflation Hedge | Poor (especially growth stocks) | Good (prices tend to rise with inflation) |
| Correlation with Economy | High positive correlation | Varied (some positive, some negative or low) |
| Liquidity | Generally high | High for major commodities, lower for niche markets |
| Volatility | High during recessions | Can be very high, driven by supply/demand shocks |
| Diversification | Limited during broad market downturns | Strong potential, especially with assets like gold |
| Typical Returns | Historically higher long-term growth | Can provide strong cyclical returns, less consistent |
In a demand-side recession-marked by falling consumer spending and industrial output-both equities and industrial commodities like oil and copper are likely to decline. However, gold and other precious metals may rally as investors seek safety. In a supply-side shock, such as an energy crisis or prolonged supply chain disruption, equities could still suffer from rising input costs and margin pressure, while commodity prices surge. This divergence underscores the importance of understanding the root cause of economic stress when allocating capital.
Strategic Portfolio Allocation for US Investors in 2025
Building a resilient portfolio for 2025 means more than picking winners-it requires a deliberate mix of asset classes designed to respond effectively under different economic conditions. While equities remain central to long-term growth, overreliance on stocks increases vulnerability during downturns. Commodities, particularly gold and energy, can act as ballast, reducing overall portfolio volatility and preserving purchasing power.
A strategic asset allocation might include a core holding in broad-market equity ETFs, overweighted in defensive sectors, supplemented by a tactical allocation to commodities based on macroeconomic signals. For example, if inflation remains stubborn and the Federal Reserve maintains higher rates, a modest allocation to gold or a diversified commodity ETF could enhance risk-adjusted returns. Conversely, if a deep demand contraction appears likely, focusing on high-quality dividend payers and cash-rich companies may be wiser.
Monitoring the Fed’s monetary policy is critical. Rate cuts typically support equities by lowering borrowing costs and stimulating growth, but they can also weaken the dollar-boosting commodity prices. Quantitative easing can amplify this effect. On the flip side, aggressive tightening to fight inflation can pressure both stocks and commodities, especially if it leads to a hard landing. Staying informed through FOMC statements and economic projections helps investors anticipate shifts in policy direction.
The Nuance of Commodity-Related Equities vs. Direct Commodity Investment
US investors have two main paths to gain exposure to commodities: through stocks of commodity-producing companies or by investing directly in the underlying assets.
- Commodity-Related Equities: This includes companies like ExxonMobil (oil), Newmont Corporation (gold), or Bunge Limited (agriculture). These stocks offer indirect commodity exposure while providing additional benefits such as dividends, corporate governance, and growth potential. They’re also more accessible-traded on standard exchanges and held in regular brokerage accounts.
- Direct Commodity Investment: This involves buying futures contracts, commodity-backed ETFs (like SPDR Gold Shares, GLD), or physical assets. These vehicles provide purer price exposure and are often more effective as inflation hedges. However, futures trading requires expertise, and some ETFs face structural issues like contango. Tax-wise, futures are treated under Section 1256, with a blended 60/40 capital gains rate, while certain commodity funds issue K-1 tax forms, adding complexity.
The choice depends on risk tolerance, time horizon, and investment goals. Investors seeking stability and income might prefer commodity-related equities. Those focused on inflation protection and diversification may opt for direct exposure via ETFs or futures.
How US Investors Can Access Commodities and Equities
Accessing equities is straightforward: most Americans use brokerage accounts to buy individual stocks, index funds, or sector-specific ETFs. Commodities require a bit more nuance but are still widely available through regulated channels.
- Stocks and Equity ETFs: Standard offerings on platforms like Fidelity, Charles Schwab, or Vanguard.
- Commodity ETFs: Funds like GLD (gold), USO (oil), or DBC (broad commodities) provide easy access without trading futures.
- Mutual Funds: Professionally managed funds that may include commodity equities or futures positions.
- Futures Contracts: Traded on exchanges like the CME Group, these require a futures-approved brokerage account and carry higher risk due to leverage.
- Options: Derivatives that allow strategic plays on commodity or equity price movements.
Regulatory oversight is strong in the US. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) regulates stocks and ETFs, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and National Futures Association (NFA) oversee futures and derivatives. Choosing a compliant broker is essential for safety and transparency.
Top Brokerage Platforms for US Investors: Commodities & Equities in 2025
Selecting the right platform can make a significant difference in execution, research access, and cost efficiency. Here’s a comparison of three leading brokers serving US investors with strong offerings in both equities and commodities.
| Broker | Regulation (US) | Commodity Access for US Investors | Equity Access for US Investors | Platforms & Features | Key Advantages for US Investors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Moneta Markets | FCA, FSCA, FSA (Globally reputable; US clients may access via specific product offerings or related instruments. Holds FCA license, ensuring strong international oversight.) | Offers a wide range of CFDs on commodities (e.g., crude oil, gold, silver) globally. For US investors, direct retail CFD trading is restricted, but Moneta Markets’ advanced platforms and competitive pricing may be relevant for those with international accounts or seeking related instruments. | Provides CFDs on major global indices and stocks. US investors can leverage its robust analytical tools for market research and portfolio management, especially when managing global exposure. | MetaTrader 4 (MT4), MetaTrader 5 (MT5), Moneta WebTrader. Known for excellent customer support, tight spreads, and powerful technical analysis tools. | A globally trusted broker with FCA licensing, Moneta Markets stands out for its advanced trading platforms and deep market access. While direct CFDs aren’t available to US retail traders, its infrastructure supports sophisticated analysis and execution for investors with international accounts or those using compliant instruments like commodity ETFs. |
| OANDA | CFTC, NFA | Direct access to regulated commodity futures and options on futures for US clients. Also offers forex pairs linked to commodity economies (e.g., AUD/USD). | Broad access to US and international equities through multiple account types and order options. | Proprietary fxTrade platform, MetaTrader 4 (MT4). User-friendly interface with strong charting and risk management tools. | Highly reputable with strong US regulatory compliance, OANDA offers transparent pricing and seamless access to futures markets-ideal for traders seeking direct commodity exposure. |
| IG | CFTC, NFA | Full access to commodity futures and options on futures across energy, metals, and agriculture for US clients. | Extensive selection of US and global stocks, ETFs, and options with advanced order types. | Proprietary IG platform, MetaTrader 4 (MT4), ProRealTime. Offers top-tier charting, real-time data, and in-depth market research. | A global leader in multi-asset trading, IG provides exceptional depth in both equities and commodities, backed by powerful tools and extensive educational resources-perfect for active US investors. |
Note: US retail investors are generally prohibited from trading CFDs due to CFTC restrictions. Brokers like OANDA and IG offer compliant access to commodity futures, while Moneta Markets-regulated by the FCA-provides advanced platforms and competitive trading conditions that may benefit US investors managing international portfolios or using alternative instruments such as ETFs and options.
Conclusion: Building a Resilient US Portfolio for 2025
As the 2025 economic outlook remains uncertain, US investors must move beyond simple asset selection and focus on strategic resilience. Equities will continue to drive long-term growth, but their performance during recessions can be volatile and unpredictable. Commodities, while not a guaranteed safe haven, offer valuable tools for diversification, inflation protection, and risk mitigation-especially when the downturn stems from supply disruptions or rising prices.
The key is balance. A well-constructed portfolio doesn’t eliminate risk-it manages it. By combining defensive equities, selective commodity exposure (via ETFs or futures), and disciplined rebalancing, investors can navigate turbulence without abandoning long-term goals. Whether through commodity-producing stocks or direct price exposure, understanding the mechanics and risks of each asset class is critical.
Ultimately, success hinges on staying informed, monitoring macroeconomic trends, and working with financial professionals who understand the nuances of both markets. With thoughtful planning, US investors can position themselves not just to survive the next recession-but to emerge stronger.
Are commodities a safe haven asset during a US recession?
Some commodities, most notably gold, are generally considered safe haven assets during a US recession due to their tendency to retain or increase in value during economic uncertainty. However, industrial commodities like oil or copper may decline with reduced demand. The classification as a “safe haven” depends on the specific commodity and the nature of the recession.
What is stagflation, and how do commodities and equities perform in such a scenario in the United States?
Stagflation is an economic condition characterized by slow economic growth (stagnation) combined with high inflation and high unemployment. In such a scenario, equities typically perform poorly due to declining corporate earnings and rising costs. Commodities, especially those tied to supply shortages (like energy), often perform well as their prices rise with inflation, acting as a natural hedge against the eroding purchasing power of currency. For US investors, allocating to commodities could be a key strategy during periods of stagflation.
How do interest rates affect the performance of commodities vs. equities during an economic downturn in the US?
During an economic downturn in the US, falling interest rates (often implemented by the Federal Reserve to stimulate the economy) can be positive for equities as they reduce borrowing costs for companies and make future earnings more valuable. Lower rates can also weaken the US dollar, which often supports commodity prices (as they become cheaper for foreign buyers). Conversely, rising interest rates, especially during the onset of a recession, can negatively impact both asset classes, increasing borrowing costs for companies and potentially strengthening the dollar, which can depress commodity prices.
Should I completely avoid equities during a recession in the United States?
Completely avoiding equities during a recession in the United States is generally not recommended for long-term investors. While bear markets can be painful, they often present opportunities to buy high-quality companies at discounted prices. A diversified portfolio, including defensive stocks and potentially some commodity exposure, can help weather the downturn. Timing the market perfectly is challenging, and missing the early stages of a recovery can significantly impact long-term returns.
What are the best types of commodities for US investors to consider during a bear market?
During a bear market, US investors often consider commodities like gold and silver due to their safe-haven characteristics. Energy commodities (oil, natural gas) can also perform well if the recession is caused by supply shocks rather than demand destruction. Agricultural commodities can offer stability as demand for food remains relatively inelastic. The “best” type depends on the specific economic conditions driving the bear market.
Can commodity ETFs protect my US portfolio against inflation in 2025?
Yes, commodity ETFs can be an effective tool for US investors to protect their portfolios against inflation in 2025. Many commodities, being raw materials, see their prices rise in inflationary environments. Investing in a broad-based commodity ETF or specific commodity ETFs (e.g., gold ETFs) can help maintain purchasing power when the value of the dollar declines. Platforms like Moneta Markets, while primarily known for global CFDs, offer advanced tools for market analysis that can support informed decisions around commodity-related instruments available to US investors, such as commodity ETFs.
How does the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy impact commodities and equities during a US recession?
The Federal Reserve’s monetary policy, particularly interest rate adjustments and quantitative easing/tightening, profoundly impacts both commodities and equities. During a recession, the Fed typically lowers interest rates to stimulate economic activity, which can eventually support equity prices and potentially weaken the dollar, thus boosting commodity values. Conversely, if the Fed tightens policy (raises rates) to combat inflation, it can dampen both asset classes. Understanding the Fed’s stance, as published in FOMC statements and projections, is crucial for US investors.
What are the tax implications for US investors trading commodities vs. equities?
For US investors, tax implications differ significantly. Equities (stocks, equity ETFs) are subject to capital gains tax (short-term for assets held under a year, long-term for over a year). Direct commodity investments via futures contracts are typically subject to Section 1256 contracts, which are taxed at a 60/40 blend of long-term and short-term capital gains rates, regardless of holding period. Some commodity ETFs are structured as partnerships (K-1 forms) with different tax treatments. It’s essential for US investors to consult with a tax professional to understand the specific implications for their commodity and equity investments. For advanced trading strategies, using a broker like Moneta Markets that provides clear transaction records can simplify tax reporting for US investors, especially for those managing diverse global portfolios or related instruments.
English
Be First to Comment